In Labor and Birth Care

The Leapfrog Group, which collects data on a voluntary basis from hospitals and compares results with national standards in order to evaluate quality of care, opens its 2015 report on U.S. maternity care with: “[T]here is substantial evidence that U.S. hospitals overuse medical interventions, exposing mothers and babies to unnecessary health risks from C-Sections, episiotomies, and early elective deliveries.” With nearly half (1750) of U.S. hospitals responding:

  • 16% delivered more than 5% of babies electively before 39 weeks, although that being said, the national average early elective delivery rate has fallen from 17% to 3% since Leapfrog first reported this measure in 2010,
  • 60% had cesarean rates exceeding 23.9% in low-risk 1st-time mothers (one, head-down baby, 37 wk gestation or more), a target rate much higher than optimal, and
  • 68% had episiotomy rates greater than 5%.

Furthermore, cesarean rates varied widely among hospitals. In one East Coast city, they ranged from 10% to 54%; in a Midwest city, the range was 12% to 40%; and a West Coast city reported rates ranging from 19% to 40%–and that was after excluding hospitals reporting rates greater than 55%.

In addition, 78% of hospitals failed to meet standards for handling high-risk deliveries, which were that 80% of mothers delivering babies weighing less than 1500 g (3 lb 5 oz) received steroids prior to delivery (to mature fetal lungs), and either the hospital delivered at least 50 such babies per year or the hospital maintained a lower-than-average morbidity/mortality rate among these babies. All in all, only 1% of responding hospitals met all four targets.

The Take-Away: Hospitals and care providers are far from alike. Ask questions. Choose carefully.


Learn more about obtaining optimal care .

Learn more about preventing the preventable cesarean .


Recommended Posts
  • Choosing a Place of Birth during COVID-19 (free eBook)

    Sign up to get the free eBook download, “Choosing a Place of Birth During COVID-19”

  • Choosing a Place of Birth during COVID-19 (free eBook)

    Sign up to receive the free eBook, “Choosing a Place of Birth During COVID-19”

  • Apply to be a CBU Partner

  • Newsletter Signup Form:

    Your contact info will be used solely to send you news on birth issues that we think may interest you.

    Be sure to add to your contact list to ensure receiving CBU communications.